(i) Atomic number: unchanged, still 12.

The atomic number counts protons in the nucleus, and the nucleus was not touched — the substitution happened outside it.
(ii) Atomic mass: it increases — the atom becomes measurably heavier.
Normally the $\displaystyle 12$ electrons can be ignored in mass calculations because an electron's mass is almost negligible.
Here the $\displaystyle 12$ replacement particles together carry \(\displaystyle 12 \times 500 = 6000\) times an electron's mass, which is no longer something you may throw away.
(iii) Mass number: unchanged, still 24.
Mass number counts nucleons only: \(\displaystyle A = \text{protons} + \text{neutrons} = 12 + 12 = 24\). Particles outside the nucleus never enter this count, however heavy they are.
(iv) Overall charge: unchanged — the atom is still neutral, total charge zero.
The hypothetical particles carry the same charge as electrons, so $\displaystyle 12$ of them still cancel the \(\displaystyle +12\) of the protons exactly.
Charge and mass are independent properties: making a particle heavier does not make it more negative.