SolveItClass 9 · NCERT

NCERT Solutions · Class 9 Science Journey Inside the Atom

33 questions · 19 still being checked

Pause and Ponder 8.1 (part 1 of 23)

  1. Exercise 8.1

    Suppose you made up your own ‘atom’, as Thomson described, using clay for the positive charge and small beads for the electrons spread through it. What will happen if: (i) the positive charge on the clay is lesser than the total negative charge of the beads? (ii) by mistake, the clay itself carries a bit of negative charge? Would your model still represent a neutral atom?

    Not cross-checked

    NCERT prints no numerical answer for this exercise, so this working has not been cross-checked against the book.

    (i) The model would carry a net negative charge — it would no longer stand for a neutral atom.
    NCERT_Solution_Class9_Science_Ch8_PP_Q8-1
    Thomson's atom is neutral only because the positive charge of the sphere exactly cancels the total negative charge of the electrons inside it.
    With less positive charge on the clay than the beads carry between them, some negative charge is left unbalanced.
    What you would be showing is a negatively charged particle, not an atom.
    (ii) No — it would still not represent a neutral atom.
    If the clay itself is a bit negative, then everything in the model is negative: negative clay plus negative beads, with nothing positive to cancel either.
    It also destroys Thomson's central idea, which needs a sphere of positive charge for the electrons to be embedded in.
    To repair the model, the clay must carry a positive charge exactly equal in size to the total negative charge on all the beads.