Exercise 3.11
A passenger arriving in a new town wishes to go from the station to a hotel located km away on a straight road from the station. A dishonest cabman takes him along a circuitous path km long and reaches the hotel in min. What is
(a)
the average speed of the taxi,
(b)
the magnitude of average velocity ? Are the two equal ?
NCERT’s answer
(a)
49.$\displaystyle 3$ km \(\displaystyle h^{-1}\) ; (b) $\displaystyle 21.4$ km \(\displaystyle h^{-1}\). No, the average speed equals average velocity magnitude only for a straight path.
Average speed looks at how far the wheels actually turned; average velocity looks only at where you ended up relative to where you started. For a route that bends, those are two different numbers — and comparing them is exactly the point of this question.Average speed is defined as\[v_{\text{avg}} = \frac{\text{total path length}}{\text{total time taken}}
\]Here the path length is the actual distance covered along the road, however curved it is — the cab's odometer reading, not the straight-line map distance.Average velocity, by contrast, is a vector defined as\[\vec{v}_{\text{avg}} = \frac{\Delta \vec{r}}{\Delta t} = \frac{\text{displacement}}{\text{total time taken}}
\]Displacement is the straight-line vector from the starting point (station) to the ending point (hotel), regardless of the path taken to get there. The question asks only for its magnitude, so no direction needs to be reported here.Before substituting, convert the time to hours so it matches the kilometre data:\[\Delta t = 28\ \text{min} = \frac{28}{60}\ \text{h} = \frac{7}{15}\ \text{h}
\](A common slip is plugging minutes straight into a km/h formula — always convert to a consistent unit pair first.)(a) Average speedThe actual road path is $\displaystyle 23$ km long, so\[v_{\text{avg}} = \frac{23\ \text{km}}{\dfrac{7}{15}\ \text{h}} = 23 \times \frac{15}{7}\ \text{km/h} = \frac{345}{7}\ \text{km/h} = 49.29\ldots\ \text{km/h}
\]All three given quantities ($\displaystyle 23$ km, $\displaystyle 10$ km, $\displaystyle 28$ min) carry two significant figures, so the result is rounded to two significant figures at the end:\[v_{\text{avg}} \approx 49\ \text{km/h}
\](b) Magnitude of average velocityThe displacement is the straight road distance between station and hotel, $\displaystyle 10$ km — not the $\displaystyle 23$ km actually driven:\[|\vec{v}_{\text{avg}}| = \frac{10\ \text{km}}{\dfrac{7}{15}\ \text{h}} = 10 \times \frac{15}{7}\ \text{km/h} = \frac{150}{7}\ \text{km/h} = 21.43\ldots\ \text{km/h}
\]Rounded to two significant figures:\[|\vec{v}_{\text{avg}}| \approx 21\ \text{km/h}
\]Are the two equal? No. Average speed ($\displaystyle 49$ km/h) is larger than the magnitude of average velocity ($\displaystyle 21$ km/h), and this is not a coincidence: distance travelled along a path can never be less than the magnitude of the net displacement between its endpoints, and it is strictly greater whenever the path is not a straight line. Since the cabman's route was circuitous ($\displaystyle 23$ km of driving to cover a $\displaystyle 10$ km straight-line gap), the two quantities differ — the only case in which they would come out equal is a trip made entirely along a straight line in one direction.Answer: (a) Average speed ≈ $\displaystyle 49$ km/h; (b) Magnitude of average velocity ≈ $\displaystyle 21$ km/h; the two are not equal because the actual path ($\displaystyle 23$ km) is longer than the straight-line displacement ($\displaystyle 10$ km).