Two tests decide every part — but only after a third one is passed. A function represents a
travelling wave if \(\displaystyle x\) and \(\displaystyle t\) enter only through the single combination \(\displaystyle x-vt\) or \(\displaystyle x+vt\); it represents a
stationary wave if it separates as (a shape in \(\displaystyle x\)) \(\displaystyle \times\) (an oscillation in \(\displaystyle t\)), so that the pattern stays put and only breathes up and down. Before either test, the function must be a physically possible displacement at all: real, finite and single-valued for every \(\displaystyle x\) and every \(\displaystyle t\), and it must satisfy the wave equation
\[\frac{\partial^{2}y}{\partial x^{2}}=\frac{1}{v^{2}}\,\frac{\partial^{2}y}{\partial t^{2}}\]
where \(\displaystyle v\) is the wave speed. A function that fails
that is the "none at all" case.
(a) \(\displaystyle y = 2\cos(3x)\,\sin(10t)\)This is already a product of a function of \(\displaystyle x\) alone and a function of \(\displaystyle t\) alone, which is the signature of a stationary wave. Comparing with \(\displaystyle y = 2a\cos kx\,\sin\omega t\):
\[k = 3,\qquad \omega = 10 .\]
Every particle performs simple harmonic motion of the same angular frequency \(\displaystyle \omega = 10\), with an amplitude \(\displaystyle 2\cos 3x\) that depends on where the particle sits. The nodes are the points that never move, \(\displaystyle \cos 3x = 0\):
\[3x = (2n+1)\frac{\pi}{2}\quad\Rightarrow\quad x = (2n+1)\frac{\pi}{6},\qquad n = 0,1,2,\dots\]
Using \(\displaystyle 2\sin A\cos B = \sin(A+B)+\sin(A-B)\) with \(\displaystyle A = 10t\), \(\displaystyle B = 3x\),
\[y = \sin(10t+3x) + \sin(10t-3x),\]
so it is the sum of two identical harmonic waves running in opposite directions with speed \(\displaystyle v = \omega/k = 10/3 \approx 3.3\) units. That is exactly how a stationary wave is made.
Stationary wave.(b) \(\displaystyle y = 2\sqrt{x-vt}\)This is the part that traps people: \(\displaystyle x\) and \(\displaystyle t\) do appear only through \(\displaystyle x-vt\), so the travelling-wave
form is satisfied and it is tempting to tick "travelling". The form is necessary but not sufficient — the function must also be a possible displacement everywhere.
For \(\displaystyle x < vt\) the quantity \(\displaystyle x-vt\) is negative and \(\displaystyle y\) is imaginary. A displacement cannot be imaginary.
As \(\displaystyle x-vt \to \infty\), \(\displaystyle y \to \infty\). A displacement cannot be unbounded; no finite energy source could produce it.
So there is no region of \(\displaystyle x\) and \(\displaystyle t\) in which this is a legitimate wave.
None at all — an unacceptable function for any wave.(c) \(\displaystyle y = 3\sin(5x-0.5t) + 4\cos(5x-0.5t)\)Write \(\displaystyle \theta = 5x - 0.5t\) and combine the two terms using \(\displaystyle a\sin\theta + b\cos\theta = R\sin(\theta+\phi)\) with \(\displaystyle R = \sqrt{a^{2}+b^{2}}\) and \(\displaystyle \tan\phi = b/a\):
\[R = \sqrt{3^{2}+4^{2}} = \sqrt{9+16} = \sqrt{25} = 5,\qquad \phi = \tan^{-1}\!\left(\frac{4}{3}\right) = 0.927\ \text{rad}\ (53.1^{\circ}).\]
\[y = 5\sin\!\left(5x - 0.5t + 0.927\right).\]
It is a single sine of one argument, and that argument contains \(\displaystyle x\) and \(\displaystyle t\) only through
\[5x - 0.5t = 5\left(x - 0.1\,t\right),\]
which is the combination \(\displaystyle x - vt\). Comparing with \(\displaystyle y = A\sin(kx-\omega t+\phi)\):
\[k = 5,\qquad \omega = 0.5,\qquad v = \frac{\omega}{k} = \frac{0.5}{5} = 0.1 .\]
The minus sign between \(\displaystyle kx\) and \(\displaystyle \omega t\) means the pattern moves towards
increasing \(\displaystyle x\) — a direction is part of this answer, not an optional extra. Amplitude \(\displaystyle 5\), speed \(\displaystyle 0.1\) in the units of the question (\(\displaystyle 0.1\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}\) if \(\displaystyle x\) is in metres and \(\displaystyle t\) in seconds), quoted to the one significant figure the data carry.
Travelling harmonic wave, moving in the \(\displaystyle +x\) direction.(d) \(\displaystyle y = \cos x\,\sin t + \cos 2x\,\sin 2t\)Take each term on its own. \(\displaystyle \cos x\,\sin t\) is separable, so it is a stationary wave with \(\displaystyle k_1 = 1,\ \omega_1 = 1\); \(\displaystyle \cos 2x\,\sin 2t\) is separable, so it is a stationary wave with \(\displaystyle k_2 = 2,\ \omega_2 = 2\). Both have the same speed \(\displaystyle \omega/k = 1\), so both are legitimate waves on the same medium, and the sum of two solutions of the wave equation is again a solution (superposition principle). Checking directly for the whole function:
\[\frac{\partial^{2}y}{\partial x^{2}} = -\cos x\,\sin t - 4\cos 2x\,\sin 2t,\qquad \frac{\partial^{2}y}{\partial t^{2}} = -\cos x\,\sin t - 4\cos 2x\,\sin 2t,\]
so \(\displaystyle \partial^{2}y/\partial x^{2} = \partial^{2}y/\partial t^{2}\), which is the wave equation with \(\displaystyle v = 1\). It is also bounded, \(\displaystyle |y| \le 2\). So this
is an acceptable wave function; it cannot be put in the "none at all" box, and that is the box people wrongly reach for here. Category (iii) is for functions like (b) that could never be a displacement — not for functions that merely look complicated.
Is it travelling? At \(\displaystyle t = 0\), \(\displaystyle y = \cos x\,\sin 0 + \cos 2x\,\sin 0 = 0\) for every \(\displaystyle x\). A travelling wave \(\displaystyle y = f(x-vt)\) just slides a fixed profile along, so if the profile is zero everywhere at one instant, \(\displaystyle f\) is identically zero and the wave is zero for all time. Here \(\displaystyle y\) is not zero at later times — at \(\displaystyle x = \pi/2\), for instance, \(\displaystyle y = -\sin 2t\). So it does not travel, and no energy is carried along the string on average.
Not travelling, and a genuine wave, leaves the stationary category. The honest description is the one to write down: it is the
superposition of two stationary waves, of angular frequencies \(\displaystyle 1\) and \(\displaystyle 2\). It is worth seeing why that phrasing is used rather than "a stationary wave" flat: the sum does not factorise as (function of \(\displaystyle x\))\(\displaystyle \times\)(function of \(\displaystyle t\)), and it has no permanent nodes — a node would need \(\displaystyle \cos x = 0\) and \(\displaystyle \cos 2x = 0\) at the same \(\displaystyle x\), but \(\displaystyle \cos 2x = 2\cos^{2}x - 1 = -1\) wherever \(\displaystyle \cos x = 0\). Each particle still oscillates about its mean position with a fixed period \(\displaystyle 2\pi\), but with two frequencies mixed in rather than one. The pattern stays where it is; it does not propagate.
Stationary — a superposition of two stationary waves.Answer: (a) stationary wave (nodes at \(\displaystyle x=(2n+1)\pi/6\)); (b) none at all — \(\displaystyle 2\sqrt{x-vt}\) is imaginary for \(\displaystyle x<vt\) and unbounded for large \(\displaystyle x-vt\), so it is an unacceptable function for any wave; (c) travelling harmonic wave, \(\displaystyle y=5\sin(5x-0.5t+0.927)\), moving in the \(\displaystyle +x\) direction with speed \(\displaystyle v=\omega/k=0.1\) (\(\displaystyle 0.1\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}\) for \(\displaystyle x\) in metres, \(\displaystyle t\) in seconds); (d) stationary — the superposition of two stationary waves of angular frequencies \(\displaystyle 1\) and \(\displaystyle 2\).