Exercise 8.11
A kg mass, fastened to the end of a steel wire of unstretched length m, is whirled in a vertical circle with an angular velocity of rev/s at the bottom of the circle. The cross-sectional area of the wire is . Calculate the elongation of the wire when the mass is at the lowest point of its path.
Not cross-checked
This solution has not been cross-checked against the answer printed in NCERT.
NCERT’s answer
1.$\displaystyle 539$ × \(\displaystyle 10^{-4}\) m
At the lowest point the wire has two jobs at once: it holds the weight up and it supplies the centripetal force. Both loads pull on the same wire, so the tension there is bigger than the weight alone — and it is that total tension, not \(\displaystyle mg\), that stretches the wire.Step $\displaystyle 1$ — Convert everything to SI, including the angular velocity.The rate of turning is given in revolutions per second. One revolution is \(\displaystyle 2\pi\) radians, and every formula below (\(\displaystyle a_c=\omega^2 r\)) needs \(\displaystyle \omega\) in radians per second:\[\omega = 2\pi \nu = 2\pi \times 2.0\ \text{rev/s} = 4\pi\ \text{rad/s} = 12.566\ \text{rad s}^{-1}
\]This is the step people get wrong. Writing \(\displaystyle \omega = 2\ \text{rad s}^{-1}\) straight off the page loses a factor of \(\displaystyle (2\pi)^2 \approx 39.5\) in the centripetal term.The area is given in \(\displaystyle \text{cm}^2\), and \(\displaystyle 1\ \text{cm}^2 = 10^{-4}\ \text{m}^2\) (the conversion factor is squared too):\[A = 0.065\ \text{cm}^2 = 0.065 \times 10^{-4}\ \text{m}^2 = 6.5\times10^{-6}\ \text{m}^2
\]Also: \(\displaystyle m = 14.5\ \text{kg}\), \(\displaystyle L = 1.0\ \text{m}\) (the unstretched length, which is also the radius of the circle), \(\displaystyle g = 9.8\ \text{m s}^{-2}\), and for steel Young's modulus \(\displaystyle Y = 2.0\times10^{11}\ \text{N m}^{-2}\).Step $\displaystyle 2$ — Newton's second law along the wire, at the lowest point.At the bottom of the circle the centre of the circle is directly above the mass, so the net upward force must equal the centripetal force \(\displaystyle m\omega^2 L\). Taking upward as positive, with \(\displaystyle T\) the tension (up) and \(\displaystyle mg\) the weight (down):\[T - mg = m\omega^{2}L \qquad\Longrightarrow\qquad T = m\left(g + \omega^{2}L\right)
\]Here \(\displaystyle T\) is the tension in newtons, \(\displaystyle m\) the mass in kg, \(\displaystyle g\) the acceleration due to gravity, \(\displaystyle \omega\) the angular velocity in rad s\(\displaystyle ^{-1}\), and \(\displaystyle L\) the radius of the circular path.Substituting:\[\omega^{2}L = (12.566\ \text{s}^{-1})^{2}\times 1.0\ \text{m} = 157.91\ \text{m s}^{-2}
\]
\[T = 14.5\ \text{kg}\times\left(9.8 + 157.91\right)\ \text{m s}^{-2} = 14.5 \times 167.71 = 2431.8\ \text{N}
\]Worth pausing on the two pieces: the weight contributes only \(\displaystyle mg = 14.5\times 9.8 = 142.1\ \text{N}\), while the whirling contributes \(\displaystyle m\omega^2 L = 14.5 \times 157.91 = 2289.7\ \text{N}\). The spinning dominates by a factor of about $\displaystyle 16$ — the wire is nowhere near just "holding a hanging mass".Step $\displaystyle 3$ — Apply the definition of Young's modulus.Young's modulus is longitudinal stress divided by longitudinal strain:\[Y = \frac{\text{stress}}{\text{strain}} = \frac{T/A}{\Delta L/L}
\qquad\Longrightarrow\qquad
\Delta L = \frac{T L}{A Y}
\]where \(\displaystyle \Delta L\) is the elongation, \(\displaystyle L\) the original length, \(\displaystyle A\) the cross-sectional area and \(\displaystyle Y\) Young's modulus.\[\Delta L = \frac{2431.8\ \text{N}\times 1.0\ \text{m}}{\left(6.5\times10^{-6}\ \text{m}^{2}\right)\left(2.0\times10^{11}\ \text{N m}^{-2}\right)}
= \frac{2431.8\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}}{1.3\times10^{6}\ \text{N}}
\]The newtons cancel and metres survive, as an elongation must:\[\Delta L = 1.871\times10^{-3}\ \text{m}
\]Step $\displaystyle 4$ — Round once, at the end.The length \(\displaystyle 1.0\ \text{m}\) and the area \(\displaystyle 0.065\ \text{cm}^2\) each carry two significant figures, so the answer is limited to two:\[\Delta L \approx 1.9\times10^{-3}\ \text{m} = 1.9\ \text{mm}
\]The wire stretches along its own length, i.e. radially outward — downward — at the lowest point.A note on the printed key. NCERT's answer for this exercise, \(\displaystyle 1.539\times10^{-4}\ \text{m}\), is not what the question as printed gives. That number is exactly what you get by putting \(\displaystyle \omega = 2\ \text{rad s}^{-1}\) into the same working: then \(\displaystyle \omega^2 L = 4.0\ \text{m s}^{-2}\), \(\displaystyle T = 14.5\times(9.8+4.0) = 200.1\ \text{N}\), and \(\displaystyle \Delta L = 200.1/(1.3\times10^{6}) = 1.539\times10^{-4}\ \text{m}\) — the key's digits reproduced exactly. So the key used the number "$\displaystyle 2$" as though it were already in rad s\(\displaystyle ^{-1}\), while the question says $\displaystyle 2$ rev/s. Converting revolutions to radians multiplies the centripetal term by \(\displaystyle (2\pi)^2 \approx 39.5\), which is why the two results differ by roughly a factor of $\displaystyle 12$ once the weight term is included. Take the question at its word and the elongation is \(\displaystyle 1.9\ \text{mm}\).Answer: \(\displaystyle \Delta L = 1.9\times10^{-3}\ \text{m}\) (about \(\displaystyle 1.9\ \text{mm}\)), the wire stretching along its length — downward — at the lowest point; the textbook's printed \(\displaystyle 1.539\times10^{-4}\ \text{m}\) follows from misreading $\displaystyle 2$ rev/s as $\displaystyle 2$ rad/s.