Exercise 9.11
Can Bernoulli’s equation be used to describe the flow of water through a rapid in a river ? Explain.
Not cross-checked
This solution has not been cross-checked against the answer printed in NCERT.
NCERT’s answer
No, Bernoulli’s principle applies to streamline flow only.
Bernoulli's equation holds only for smooth, streamline flow — a rapid is turbulent, so the equation breaks down.Bernoulli's equation for a fluid moving along a streamline is
\[p + \frac{1}{2}\rho v^2 + \rho g h = \text{constant}
\]
where \(\displaystyle p\) is the pressure, \(\displaystyle \rho\) is the fluid density, \(\displaystyle v\) is its speed, and \(\displaystyle h\) is its height above some reference level. This result comes from applying the work–energy theorem to a fluid element, and it rests on three assumptions built into the derivation:
the flow is steady (streamline/laminar) — at any fixed point, the velocity of the fluid does not change with time,
the fluid is incompressible, and
the fluid is non-viscous, so no mechanical energy is lost to internal friction as the fluid moves.
A rapid in a river is, by definition, a stretch where the water surges over rocks and a steep bed with high speed. Under these conditions the flow becomes turbulent: the water breaks into swirling eddies and whorls, and the velocity at a given point fluctuates rapidly and unpredictably with time instead of following a smooth, well-defined streamline. This is precisely the condition Bernoulli's equation excludes — the "steady, streamline flow" assumption fails.There is also energy loss to consider. In turbulent flow, a large amount of the water's kinetic energy is dissipated as heat through internal friction between layers of fluid moving chaotically against each other (this is why rapids are frothy and noisy). Bernoulli's equation is a statement that mechanical energy per unit volume is conserved along a streamline; once energy is being dissipated by turbulence, that conservation no longer holds.For both reasons — the flow is not steady/streamline, and mechanical energy is not conserved because of turbulent dissipation — Bernoulli's equation cannot be used to describe the flow of water through a rapid.**Answer: No. Bernoulli's equation applies only to steady, streamline (laminar) flow of a non-viscous fluid where mechanical energy is conserved. The flow through a rapid is turbulent — the velocity at each point fluctuates rapidly with time and energy is dissipated through internal friction — so the conditions needed for Bernoulli's equation are not satisfied.