Exercise 4.11
A truck starts from rest and accelerates uniformly at m . At t = s, a stone is dropped by a person standing on the top of the truck ( m high from the ground). What are the
(a)
velocity, and
(b)
acceleration of the stone at t = 11s ? (Neglect air resistance.)
Not cross-checked
This solution has not been cross-checked against the answer printed in NCERT.
NCERT’s answer
(a)
Velocity of car ( at t = $\displaystyle 10$ s ) = $\displaystyle 0$ + $\displaystyle 2$ × $\displaystyle 10$ = $\displaystyle 20$ m \(\displaystyle s^{-1}\) By the First Law, the horizontal component of velocity is $\displaystyle 20$ m \(\displaystyle s^{-1}\) throughout. Vertical component of velocity (at t = 11s) = $\displaystyle 0$ + $\displaystyle 10$ × $\displaystyle 1$ = $\displaystyle 10$ m \(\displaystyle s^{-1}\) Velocity of stone (at t = 11s) = $\displaystyle 20$ $\displaystyle 10$ $\displaystyle 500$ $\displaystyle 22$ $\displaystyle 4$ $\displaystyle 2$ $\displaystyle 2$ + = = . -$\displaystyle 1$ m s at an angle of \(\displaystyle tan^{-1}\) ( ½) with the horizontal. (b)$\displaystyle 10$ m \(\displaystyle s^{-2}\) vertically downwards.
Once the stone leaves the person's hand, the truck can no longer push it — only gravity acts on it. Everything about this problem comes from separating "what the stone was doing while riding on the truck" from "what happens to it in the air."Step $\displaystyle 1$: The stone's velocity at the instant of release.The truck starts from rest \(\displaystyle (u = 0) \) and accelerates uniformly at \(\displaystyle a = 2.0 \text{ m s}^{-2} \). Using Newton's first equation of motion,
\[v = u + at
\]
at \(\displaystyle t = 10\text{ s} \):
\[v = 0 + (2.0 \text{ m s}^{-2})(10 \text{ s}) = 20 \text{ m s}^{-1}
\]So at the moment the stone is dropped, it is moving horizontally at $\displaystyle 20$ m s⁻¹ — the same as the truck, because it has been riding along with it.Step $\displaystyle 2$: What happens after release — horizontal motion.The instant the stone leaves the person's hand, it is no longer in contact with the truck. With air resistance neglected, the only force on the stone is gravity, which is purely vertical. By Newton's first law, with no horizontal force acting, the stone's horizontal velocity stays exactly as it was at release: \(\displaystyle v_x = 20 \text{ m s}^{-1} \), unchanged for as long as it falls. This is the point that trips people up — the truck keeps accelerating after the stone is dropped, but that acceleration belongs to the truck, not to the stone anymore.Step $\displaystyle 3$: What happens after release — vertical motion.Vertically, the stone starts from rest (it had no vertical velocity while sitting on the truck) and falls freely under gravity, \(\displaystyle g = 10 \text{ m s}^{-2} \) (taken as given for this problem). One second after release — that is, at \(\displaystyle t = 11\text{ s} \), since the stone was dropped at \(\displaystyle t = 10\text{ s} \) — its downward speed is
\[v_y = g t' = (10 \text{ m s}^{-2})(1 \text{ s}) = 10 \text{ m s}^{-1}
\]
(A quick check that the stone is still airborne at this instant: falling $\displaystyle 6$ m from rest under \(\displaystyle g = 10 \text{ m s}^{-2} \) takes \(\displaystyle t' = \sqrt{2h/g} = \sqrt{1.2} \approx 1.095 \text{ s} \), which is later than \(\displaystyle t' = 1\text{ s} \), so the stone has not yet hit the ground.)(a) Velocity at t = $\displaystyle 11$ sThe stone's velocity is the vector sum of its unchanged horizontal part and its vertical free-fall part — this is just projectile motion, with the "launch" being horizontal instead of the more usual case of launching from the ground.
\[v = \sqrt{v_x^2 + v_y^2} = \sqrt{(20 \text{ m s}^{-1})^2 + (10 \text{ m s}^{-1})^2} = \sqrt{500} \text{ m s}^{-1} \approx 22.4 \text{ m s}^{-1}
\]Speed alone is not the full answer here — velocity is a vector, so the direction matters. Taking the angle \(\displaystyle \theta \) below the horizontal (measured from the direction the truck is moving):
\[\tan\theta = \frac{v_y}{v_x} = \frac{10}{20} = \frac{1}{2} \quad\Rightarrow\quad \theta = \tan^{-1}\!\left(\tfrac{1}{2}\right) \approx 26.6^\circ
\]So the stone moves at about $\displaystyle 22.4$ m s⁻¹, directed $\displaystyle 26.6$° below the horizontal, in the direction the truck is travelling.(b) Acceleration at t = $\displaystyle 11$ sThis is the part where it's easy to guess wrong: since the truck was accelerating and the stone was on the truck, it's tempting to think the stone's acceleration should somehow still involve the truck's \(\displaystyle 2.0 \text{ m s}^{-2} \). It does not. Acceleration comes only from the net force acting right now, and once the stone is in the air, the truck exerts no force on it at all — only gravity does. So the stone's acceleration is simply
\[a_{\text{stone}} = g = 10 \text{ m s}^{-2}, \text{ directed vertically downward.}
\]
This is true throughout the fall, not just at \(\displaystyle t = 11\text{ s} \) — the horizontal velocity is carried along unchanged (zero horizontal acceleration), while gravity alone accelerates the stone downward.Answer: (a) velocity \(\displaystyle \approx 22.4 \text{ m s}^{-1} \), directed at \(\displaystyle \tan^{-1}(1/2) \approx 26.6^\circ \) below the horizontal, in the direction of the truck's motion; (b) acceleration \(\displaystyle = 10 \text{ m s}^{-2} \), vertically downward (equal to \(\displaystyle g \), unaffected by the truck).