Exercise 5.1
Choose the correct answer. A thermodynamic state function is a quantity
(i)
used to determine heat changes
(ii)
whose value is independent of path
(iii)
used to determine pressure volume work
(iv)
whose value depends on temperature only.
Not cross-checked
This solution has not been cross-checked against the answer printed in NCERT.
NCERT’s answer
(ii)
A state function depends only on where the system is, not on how it got there.
To pick the right option, check each one against what "independent of path" means.
Internal energy \(\displaystyle U \), enthalpy \(\displaystyle H \), entropy \(\displaystyle S \), pressure \(\displaystyle p \), volume \(\displaystyle V \), and temperature \(\displaystyle T \) are all state functions: once you fix the state of the system (its pressure, volume, temperature, and composition), each of these has one fixed value, no matter which route was taken to reach that state.
Heat \(\displaystyle q \) and work \(\displaystyle w \) are different — they are path functions. The same overall change in a system (say, from state $\displaystyle 1$ to state $\displaystyle 2$) can be brought about reversibly or irreversibly, and \(\displaystyle q \) and \(\displaystyle w \) individually come out different for each route, even though their sum \(\displaystyle q + w = \Delta U \) is always the same (this is the first law, and it works only because \(\displaystyle U \) is a state function).
Now check the four options:
(i)
"used to determine heat changes" — heat itself is a path function, not a state function, so a quantity defined through heat changes is not automatically state-independent. This does not define a state function.
(iii)
"used to determine pressure–volume work" — pressure–volume work, \(\displaystyle w = -p_{\text{ext}}\Delta V \), also depends on the path (for instance, whether the expansion is done in one step or reversibly in many infinitesimal steps against a continuously adjusted pressure gives different \(\displaystyle w \) for the same \(\displaystyle \Delta V \)). So this cannot be the defining property of a state function either.
(iv)
"whose value depends on temperature only" — this is too narrow. Enthalpy \(\displaystyle H \), for example, depends on both pressure and composition as well as temperature, yet it is very much a state function. Depending on temperature alone is not what makes a quantity a state function — being path-independent is.
(ii)
"whose value is independent of path" — this is exactly the definition. A state function's change between two states, \(\displaystyle \Delta X = X_{\text{final}} - X_{\text{initial}} \), depends only on the initial and final states, never on the sequence of steps connecting them. That is the property shared by \(\displaystyle U \), \(\displaystyle H \), \(\displaystyle S \), \(\displaystyle p \), \(\displaystyle V \), and \(\displaystyle T \), and it is the one property that correctly separates state functions from path functions like \(\displaystyle q \) and \(\displaystyle w \).
Answer: (ii) — a thermodynamic state function is a quantity whose value is independent of path.