✓ Board-verified
Business Studies · 2026 · 4 marks
CBSE 2026 · Region 5 · Set 3 · Q30
‘Ratan Ltd.’ and ‘Lara Ltd.’ are two companies with each having a
capital employed of ₹ $\displaystyle 20,00$,000. ‘Ratan Ltd.’ had raised funds by
issuing shares whereas ‘Lara Ltd.’s’ capital has $\displaystyle 60$% equity (in shares
of ₹ $\displaystyle 100$ each) and $\displaystyle 40$% debt (comprising of $\displaystyle 8$% debentures). Both the companies have a Return on Investment of $\displaystyle 10$% and the tax rate is
%.
State with reason which company will be able to give a better return
to the shareholders. Show your calculations clearly.
Marking-scheme solution
Workings:
Lara Ltd. will be able to give better returns to the shareholders.
Reason: Due to presence of debt in capital structure and Return On
Investment being higher than the cost of debt, Lara Ltd. will be able to give
higher returns to its shareholders.
| Details | Ratan Ltd.(₹) | Lara Ltd.(₹) |
| Share Capital (of ₹$\displaystyle 100$ each) | $\displaystyle 20,00,000$ | $\displaystyle 12,00,000$ |
| $\displaystyle 8$% Debentures | - | $\displaystyle 8,00,000$ |
| Capital Employed | $\displaystyle 20,00,000$ | $\displaystyle 20,00,000$ |
| Details | Ratan Ltd.(₹) | Lara Ltd.(₹) |
| Earnings Before Interest and Tax | $\displaystyle 2,00,000$ | $\displaystyle 2,00,000$ |
| Less: Interest @ $\displaystyle 8$% p.a. | - | $\displaystyle (64,000)$ |
| Earnings Before Tax | $\displaystyle 2,00,000$ | $\displaystyle 1,36,000$ |
| Less: Tax @ $\displaystyle 40$% | $\displaystyle (80,000)$ | $\displaystyle (54,400)$ |
| Earnings After Tax | $\displaystyle 1,20,000$ | $\displaystyle 81,600$ |
| Earnings Per Share = Earnings After Tax No. of shares | = $\displaystyle 1,20,000$ $\displaystyle 20,000$ = $\displaystyle 6$ | = $\displaystyle 81,600$ $\displaystyle 12,000$ = $\displaystyle 6.8$ |
More from Financial Management
- Read the following statements carefully: Statement I: Higher fixed operating costs result in higher business…2026
- Match the factors affecting fixed capital requirements given in the Column-I with their explanations given in…2023
- 'Payal Ltd.' plans to start manufacturing solar panels which will require a significant amount of investment…2025
- State any four factors that affect the decision related to how much profit is to be distributed and how much…2023
- The risk related to inability to meet fixed financial charges like interest payment and other repayment…2025
- ‘Zenith Mall’ is a famous shopping mall in Mumbai, owned by ‘Pinnacle Group'. It is very popular for its…2023
- refers to the increase in profit earned by the equity shareholders due to the presence of fixed financial…2023
- Explain the following factors affecting the fixed capital requirements of a company: (i) Nature of Business…2025
CBSE Class 12 Business Studies past-paper question from the 2026board exam, with the answer as CBSE’s own marking scheme gives it. Where our answers come from.