Exercise 11
Let P, Q be points of trisection of AB, with P closer to A, and Q closer to B. Using your knowledge of how to find the coordinates of the midpoint of a segment, how would you find the coordinates of P and Q? Do this for the case when the points are A and B .
Not cross-checked
This solution has not been cross-checked against the answer printed in NCERT.
Split the journey into three equal steps instead of two.The idea. The midpoint formula works because going from A to B is one journey: the total change is \(\displaystyle \big(x_\mathrm{B}-x_\mathrm{A},\ y_\mathrm{B}-y_\mathrm{A}\big)\), and the midpoint is where you have completed half of that change in x and half of it in y. Trisection points are the same idea with thirds. P, the point closer to A, is reached after one third of the journey; Q is reached after two thirds. So:\[\text{compute the total step } (\Delta x,\ \Delta y),\ \text{take one third of it, and add that step on twice.} \]Doing it for A\(\displaystyle (4,7)\) and B\(\displaystyle (16,-2)\).Total step from A to B:
\[\Delta x = 16 - 4 = 12, \qquad \Delta y = -2 - 7 = -9. \]One third of the step:
\[\left(\frac{12}{3},\ \frac{-9}{3}\right) = (4,\ -3). \]Add it once to reach P, and once more to reach Q:
\[\mathrm{P} = (4+4,\ 7-3) = (8,\ 4), \qquad \mathrm{Q} = (8+4,\ 4-3) = (12,\ 1). \]And adding it a third time gives \(\displaystyle (16, -2) = \mathrm{B}\), which confirms the arithmetic.Written as a formula, this says
\[\mathrm{P} = \left(\frac{2x_\mathrm{A}+x_\mathrm{B}}{3},\ \frac{2y_\mathrm{A}+y_\mathrm{B}}{3}\right), \qquad \mathrm{Q} = \left(\frac{x_\mathrm{A}+2x_\mathrm{B}}{3},\ \frac{y_\mathrm{A}+2y_\mathrm{B}}{3}\right), \]
which for our points gives \(\displaystyle \mathrm{P}=\left(\frac{8+16}{3},\frac{14-2}{3}\right)=(8,4)\) and \(\displaystyle \mathrm{Q}=\left(\frac{4+32}{3},\frac{7-4}{3}\right)=(12,1)\), as before.Checking with midpoints - the link the question asks for. If P and Q really cut AB into three equal parts, then P must be the midpoint of A and Q, and Q must be the midpoint of P and B. Test both with the averaging rule:\[\text{midpoint of A}(4,7)\text{ and Q}(12,1) = \left(\frac{4+12}{2},\ \frac{7+1}{2}\right) = (8,\ 4) = \mathrm{P}\ \checkmark \]\[\text{midpoint of P}(8,4)\text{ and B}(16,-2) = \left(\frac{8+16}{2},\ \frac{4+(-2)}{2}\right) = (12,\ 1) = \mathrm{Q}\ \checkmark \]Checking with distances. Each of the three pieces should be the same length:
\[\mathrm{AP} = \sqrt{4^2+(-3)^2} = 5, \quad \mathrm{PQ} = \sqrt{4^2+(-3)^2} = 5, \quad \mathrm{QB} = \sqrt{4^2+(-3)^2} = 5, \]
and the whole segment is \(\displaystyle \mathrm{AB} = \sqrt{12^2+(-9)^2} = \sqrt{144+81} = \sqrt{225} = 15 = 3\times 5\). The three parts are equal and they add up to AB, so P and Q really are the points of trisection, with P nearer A.Answer: take one third of the total step from A to B and add it on twice. For A\(\displaystyle (4,7)\) and B\(\displaystyle (16,-2)\) the total step is \(\displaystyle (12,-9)\), one third of it is \(\displaystyle (4,-3)\), so \(\displaystyle \mathrm{P} = (8,\ 4)\) and \(\displaystyle \mathrm{Q} = (12,\ 1)\), with \(\displaystyle \mathrm{AP}=\mathrm{PQ}=\mathrm{QB}=5\) and \(\displaystyle \mathrm{AB}=15\).