✓ Board-verified
English · 2026 · 6 marks
CBSE 2026 · Region 3 · Set 1 · Q10
How does the method of the seagull's mother to teach her child to be independent contrast with Amanda's mother's constant nagging ? Examine how this affects the emotional responses of the seagull and Amanda.
('Two Stories about Flying' and 'Amanda!')
Official answer
From CBSE’s own marking scheme for this paper.
Seagull’s mother:
wants to make Seagull independent/ self-reliant
uses indirect method to motivate young Seagull to fly
concerned about survival and future
silent encouragement, deals strategically
builds courage and confidence in Seagull
believes in his instincts to fly
shows love but deals practically for the growth
Amanda’s mother:
always nags Amanda, strict, controlling
wants Amanda to behave perfectly
follows her ideals
constantly gives direct instructions, scolds
concerned about her appearance
concerned for social manners, behavior
tone is demanding
makes Amanda feel trapped who wants to escape from that situation
Compare and contrast
fostered autonomy in Seagull and created rebellion in Amanda
Seagull got closer to the family but Amanda wanted to move away
Seagull’s mother encouraged its emotional development whereas Amanda’s mother
restricted her natural growth
Seagull’s mother made it resilient, Amanda’s mother had excessive control
More from First Flight
- How does Valli's desire to ride the bus reflect her aspirations and challenges in context of her daily life?…2025
- What was Chubukov's reaction when he discovered the actual purpose behind Lomov's visit? (The Proposal)2026
- Describe the changing reactions of Ink, Blink and Mustard to Custard's bravado. (The Tale of Custard the…2025
- What was Chubukov's reaction when he heard about Lomov's proposal for his daughter's hand? (The Proposal)2026
- Why does Custard long for a nice safe cage? (The Tale of Custard the Dragon)2025
- What does the poet mean by the phrase 'And no one buys a ball back'? (The Ball Poem)2025
- Mention the details that Anne provides about her family in her diary. (From the Diary of Anne Frank)2026
- Amanda and Valli both represent a longing for freedom. Examine the above observation with reference to the…2025
CBSE Class 10 English past-paper question from the 2026board exam, with the answer as CBSE’s own marking scheme gives it. Where our answers come from.